64.8 F
Sunday, May 28, 2023
HomeOpinionIrate reader, soldier chastises as "un-American" the voice of opposition

Irate reader, soldier chastises as “un-American” the voice of opposition

flag.jpgI received an irate e-mail for my views on September 11, the war in Iraq and Bush’s America as a whole. I was called unpatriotic for not flag-waving Bush’s war. I was told to “grow up.” Sorry, but I did that the first time I buried a friend killed in Vietnam. He was 19.

But Iraq is not about Vietnam, and not really about September 11th; that was just the excuse that triggered a rush to war in oil-rich country.

Here’s the letter:

“Wow, did you really write that in the Clarksville Voice? If so, you really should be ashamed of yourself, and consider renouncing your American Citizenship (since you seem to be so angry and ashamed of the actions we have taken to prevent another attack) and go live among those “innocents being slaughtered” you so fondly speak of.

“I personally remember everything about that awful Tuesday morning six years ago. I was awake, but still in bed in my apartment in Nashville, TN; when one of my friends and my Dad called nearly simultaneously to alert me about this terrible “accident” at the World Trade Center. I immediately turned on Fox News and within seconds, the second plane hit the other tower, then news of the Pentagon being attacked, and then ANOTHER plane going down en route to the White House.

“This was a truly horrifying day, I wanted nothing more than to hunt down and kill those responsible for these travesties, and to this day I still do; but today, it seems, most people have a different sentiment about things.”

“For the past few days I have been trying to find a couple of random little items, like an American flag tie, or even just a lapel pin that I could wear today to honor those who were murdered by cowards, and those who have died avenging them and our nation, and guess what; at the stores I have gone to, upon asking where I might find these “commonplace” items, I am told “Oh, fourth of July is long passed, sorry.

“I hate to use bad language in a topic as near and dear to my heart, but it made me [expletive] sick. Forget about the fact I could find all the merchandise my heart desires if I wanted to display my Mexican pride, but no Stars and Stripes anything?

“It has become politically incorrect to be patriotic, no, to even care about your country and those who were murdered by terrorists, and those who died hunting down said terrorists.

“You are a published writer in what I have discerned to be an overtly liberal publication in the Clarksville (where I dunno, the 101st Airborne Division live) and Middle Tennessee area. Granted, I as a former Rakkasan [187th Airborne] and registered Republican have many, many qualms with the way Ol’ Shrub has mismanaged the country and the war, but let’s digress for a moment as to why we’re here: September 11, 2001.Yeah, it was supposed to be just an ordinary workday; so was December 7, 1941.

“To suggest that we honor those murdered by these cowards and our brave servicemen and women who died by throwing in the towel as it might be is shameful and; for lack of better words, wrong. Would I be out of line to ask if you have, (or had) any loved ones who have died as a result of the bombings (and no; I am not talking about your “tens of thousands of innocents slaughtered [in Iraq] every day)? Well I haven’t, but as a former soldier, I know that having Americans back home bashing me and my efforts in the manner in which you do certainly doesn’t make being scared, away from home, and fighting the forces of evil, any easier.

“I apologize for being so blunt, but grow up lady. Neville Chamberlain called for peace and we know how that all ended up, right? Six million dead Jews. Think about it before spewing your Anti-American rhetoric and hate.”

— Zane

First of all, we are Clarksville Online, not Clarksville Voice. And by the way, I am quite grown up. I did that growing up outside a military base in New England, where I managed to acrue no less than 17 friends on the Vietnam wall in DC. And there is nothing more hateful than war. It’s peace that’s hard.

I am familiar with war, too familiar with counting names of dead friends killed in action and weeping alongside their families. I also spent 27 years taking care of my elderly uncle; I was holding him when he died from the longterm effects of war (he was a surviving POW of WWII, paid back with a lifetime of PTSD, skin disorders from malnutrition, and too many mental and physical issues to list here).

When I wasn’t writing about all kinds of other things for a living (like murders, drunk driving victims, drug dealers, missing children and pedophiles, corrupt politicians) I spent another decade working on issues of homelessness and substance abuse with both low income women and with many men who happened to be homeless, addicted or mentally ill Vietnam vets irrevocably damaged by that earlier unwinnable war. I am quite familiar with the after effects of war (which are only belatedly and insufficiently being addressed by the Bush administration).

If we want to prevent another Sept. 11-type attack, let’s start by trying to secure our own borders and ports, stamp down hard on illegal immigration (I have no problems with legal immigration; I come from immigrant stock myself), and get Bin Laden. He’s apparently not in Iraq. If I am ashamed of anything, it is of a governmental structure so riddled with ineptitude that each day brings a new report of incompetence and wast, and evidence of amazing arrogance that has ultimately toyed with the lives of all our troops and their families.

So for now, yes, I am a dissenting American (one of many, with 73% of American having serious issues with sustaining this war according to post-presidential speech polls). I am not the only dissenter; I am not standing alone.

napalm.jpgAs for the victims, those “innocents being slaughtered,” there is little difference between the burned child running down the road in that famous Vietnam era photograph (left) and the little boy, Youssif (below, right) torched and horribly burned in Iraq and now receiving medical care here.

youssif.JPGTwo helpless victims of two pointless wars. Unconscionable horror inflicted on innocents, and it is the innocents who are usually, inevitably caught in the crossfire. Our 9-11 victims were also innocents, caught in the cross fire of fanatical governmental and religious hatred. These children did not fly a plane into the towers.

p1020148.jpgI have every respect for the troops stationed overseas, and their families at home. They suffer on many levels, all bearing the emotional scars of wartime horrors and familial separation.

Two years into this conflict (back in 2005), as I sat in a Fort Campbell church with friends from the base on Holy Saturday, I found myself exchanging the sign of peace with a soldier I didn’t know. He was alone, and he took my hand in peace, and didn’t let go. So I sat down next to him, and continued to hold the part of his hand what was not raw wounded flesh. I held this hand of a soldier I didn’t even know, this soldier whose arms were solid burns lightly bandaged, who had gouging shrapnel scars all over the parts of his that were shaved to the skin, whose leg was held together by a marvel of metal engineering with large pins anchoring this steel frame to his bones.

bill-of-rights.gifOur country was founded by dissenters, by people shedding the yoke of government they didn’t want or respect. Remember the Boston Tea Party? Or the American Revolution? And a little thing called the Bill of Rights (that little piece of paper that guaranteed our civil liberties including the right to dissent, the bill that’s been trampled by Bush’s government?).

This is government “of the people, by the people and for the people,” and I have no problem with defending ourselves and our people. But the facts are (and it has been admitted) that “we the people” were misled and outright lied to about Iraq and its relevance to September 11; our troops were sent to Iraq by an administration that did not take the time to realistically think through why they were going there (or at least, what they would tell the American people about why they were going there), what the objectives were, and how they planned to accomplish that objective — and get out. General Petraeus this week was candid about what needed to happen to win the war, and equally candid about the possibility of not being able to win this war. And many Americans, including an increasing number of legislators, hold the belief that this was the wrong war to fight and that no more lives — including yours — should be sacrificed on this particular altar.

Remember that long after Americans were grounded around the world, it was George Bush’s people who let so many members of the Bin Laden family and their money leave the country in chartered jets before they could be questioned (detaining them was not even an issue). If you want to vent anger over Sept. 11, there’s a good place to start. It’s a long way from the ending, but it is a starting point, though it may not help us catch him now.

In the meantime, I am one of many citizens who are outraged not just over the war but the web of events and actions surrounding the war that will ultimately impact every American through the next generation: the war wounds, mental and physical, the unaddressed and poorly acknowledged health impacts of Sept. 11 on New Yorkers and the rescuers from everywhere, the horrific fiscal cost that our even our grandchildren will be paying off, and the daily placement of our cherished civil liberties on the chopping block.

When our soldiers come home and need assistance, I’ll probably be one of the people helping them, sooner or later, through one of the several community programs I volunteer for. If you stay in this war long enough, I, or someone just like me, may be the one helping you as well. That what’s we peace-mongers do.

I feel deeply for all who lost their lives, and their families, on September 11. The Iraq War is not buying them justice or atonement or revenge; it is just creating more victims. Not just in Iraq. Heck, take some that war funding and pay the emerging and escalating health care costs of the survivors and emergency workers.

I would also recommend that┬ápeople try watching something other than Fox News’ one-dimensional, blatantly biased broadcasting. British, French, Italian, Asian and even Chilean broadcasts can add new dimensions to our views on the war by allowing us to see it from a global perspective, and thus reveal how our country is viewed by the other nations of the world.

Finally, I have no trouble finding patriotic memorabilia — it’s everywhere. Twin Tower pins, magnetic yellow ribbons saying “We Love Our Troops”, American flags, copies of the Bill of Rights, all proudly sitting right along side my Impeach Bush bumper stickers.



  1. The only first amendment right Zane didn’t trample in his letter intentionally or otherwise, was the freedom of religion.

    A refresher is needed:

    Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

    Everything Zane criticized Christine about in his letter is protected therein. You are doing a bang up job protecting and defending the Constitution of the United States of America, and the rights of it’s citizens to exercise their rights there, aren’t you Soldier…

  2. This is exactly what it is to be an American. I get so fed up with people who tell you “America: love it or leave it”. That is not what this country was founded on. It seems rather shortsighted of people to say this when you demonstrate any hint of dissention with the status quo. There are two things that every American should do to demonstrate their patriotism. I can tell you right now that it isn’t flying a flag on your car or in front of your home until it is in shreds. Hell it definitely isn’t wearing a flag lapel.

    If anything, these actions are demonstrations of poor flag etiquette but that it a different talk show altogether.

    The most American thing you can do is vote and constructively criticize those things you don’t like and try to change them productively.

  3. Individuals following “Zane’s” very flawed “logic” and responding to classic propaganda manipulation are the reason GeeDub was able to wreak havoc on the world with impunity for so long. Zane is willing to trample all over the Constitution and Bill of Rights by using that worn and ridiculous “shut up” O’Reilly inanity, but then tries to convince us he’s more patriotic than the writer of the piece. Good grief. Bennie Franklin said it best: “They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.”

  4. Christine, you never talked about all the work you did to help veterans, it didn’t come up until someone called you unpatriotic. As I said on the phone, you are my hero, so many times over. You get yourself to the American Red Cross to volunteer every week. You’re the first to step up to help someone or make a statement for Democracy. You support the arts and culture of our great country. I was not from a family background of helping those less fortunate. My eyes have been opened. Bill and David, thanks for also demonstrating the best that human beings can be. Thanks for your voice, “Lola wants”. This is Patriotism.

  5. That letter writer has blindly swallowed the Kool-Aid! He’s restricted himself to venues are assured of telling him what he wants to hear. Patriotism is as we define it! Wave the flag, wear a lapel pin. Don’t actually try living it. That’s too touchy-feely! Real Americans don’t do that stuff.

    Real patriotism IS calling in question actions and policies of one’s government. Dissent is what founded this nation and is guaranteed in The Constitution. Yes, The Constitution, that silly piece of parchment that GW is trying to shred at every option- warrantless spying, executive privilege, rendition, secret prisons and torture chambers on foreign soil, politcal appointments of federal judges, incompetent cabinet appointments of unqualified friends and croonies and misfits. The American Revolution was fought to throw the oppression of King George. It seems he’s found a way back into our lives. I, for one, reject him again!

    My service in Germany taught me that we have a very one-sided view of ourselves, rose-colored glasses view. Oddly enough, I was better able to enjoy the benefits of being an American overseas than anything I had known in my homeland. I resolved to never accept anything less once I returned here. “My country, right or wrong” has led to some of the worst human tragedies ever. It is a flawed philosophy, already abandoned by most of the world. It’s shameful to hear it spouted so fervorently from the mouths of those who haven’t placed their posteriors ‘on the line!’ Mike Reagan can’t pimp his adopted daddy hard enough. Fox News is anything but news. Anne Coulter is just plain scary.

    The sad truth of Iraq is this: The American govt destablized another country with no thought to the aftermath of civil services, law enforcement and control and public function and commerce. Someone apparently thought it would be like post-WWII Europe. And now we have over 37,000 dead servicemembers and over 100,000 maimed. We are responsible for the mess that is present day Iraq and the World will not let us of the hook. WE CREATED THIS MESS. Zane, when you accept that reality, you’ll have taken the first step in taking off those rose-colored glasses and becoming a true patriot. GW is not worth one more life being lost. Unfortunately, because of his arrogance and folly, many more will be lost before this disgrace is ended. GW wants to make Iraq another South Korea! Of course he hasn’t consulted the Iraqi people about that!

    Republicans cried for dissenters to give Petreaus until September to make a difference. The surge needed time to have impact and turn things around. He said it earlier this Spring, and hasn’t changed his assessment- Military victory is not possible in Iraq. Iraq requires a political victory and THAT is a longways off. It’s September and victory is STILL a long ways off!

Latest Articles